Therapy, Not Punishment Essay

Therapy, Not Punishment Essay

Length: 839 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Therapy, Not Punishment

Problems with crime have always been a concern to society. There are many different ideas about what causes it and even more ideas about how to stop it. Dr. Karl Menninger believes that our current prison system is not adequately addressing the motivation behind crime. In his article "Therapy, Not Punishment", Menninger says of the old prison system, "In its place should go a quiet, dignified, therapeutic programÉ" (544). He sets forth the claim of policy that criminals need to be treated with professional therapy. I don't think an introduction could be more clear than this.

Menninger's ideas are directed toward a wide audience of generally law-abiding citizens. This article first appeared in Harper's Magazine, a general-interest magazine that provides collections of essays and fiction. The type of person who would read a magazine such as this would probably be an educated person who is interested in the affairs of the world around them. Menninger reveals his impression of the audience in his introduction, where he says, "And from these offenses the average citizen, including the reader, is deterred by quite different restraints" (537). Armed with this vision of his audience, he presents his argument in a logical, authoritative tone that invites the reader to make the inevitable conclusion that Menninger is right.

Menninger begins to support his claim of policy by demonstrating the failures of the present penal system. He states, "Today it is no secret that our official, prison-threat theory of crime control is an utter failure" (537). He illustrates this assertion by pointing out that in England when pocket picking was punishable by hanging, pickpockets targeted the crowd that gathered to witness ...


... middle of paper ...


... a solution to crime. This method prepares the reader well for Menninger's proposals.

This logical progression through his views of the prison system is a large part of Menninger's clear, understandable tone. By keeping to his topic and remaining organized, Menninger contributes to his own credibility. He also draws credibility from his credentials and often refers to the psychiatric community as "we". Menninger wraps up his argument just as logically as it began by saying that society must make positive moves to rehabilitate criminals. His logical style and expertise provide an effective argument and reveal a well-planned solution to a serious problem.Cedric probably needed to mention that Menninger is often sarcastic and insults his opposition at least once. It is important to comment on what isn't working for a writer as well as what he does that is effective.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Punishment Or Rehabilitation?

- ... Odds are the user is going to revert right back to what got the person into jail once he or she is released. So instead of putting prisoners in a crowded jail cell they need to be put into a rehabilitation center where the individual can learn how to be a productive member of society again. Drug offenders can learn to live without dependence on substances. Rehab centers will do a much better job of helping them than prisons will. James Gilligan criticizes America’s prison system in his article “Punishment Fails....   [tags: Prison, Penology, Recidivism, Punishment]

Better Essays
1053 words (3 pages)

Capital Punishment : The Death Penalty Essays

- Capital punishment, which is known as the death penalty has been known for years as a way to punish someone has committed a crime. The death penalty has been around since the 18th century. In the 18th century, the Code of Hammurabi, which contained the first death penalty laws, was discovered. It listed different crimes that would be punishable by death. It was noted in the 18th century, there are approximately 72,000 people executed for various crimes. The first actual recorded execution was in the colonies which were led, and carried out by the Jamestown colony that the suspect was Captain George Kendall....   [tags: Capital punishment, Prison, Penology, Stoning]

Better Essays
989 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Varying Rationales and Ethical Frameworks for Punishment

- What would the criminal justice system be without punishment. Perhaps, the criminal justice system would not serve a function or cease to exist. Punishment is one of the main facets of the criminal justice system. It holds such significance that it even reflects the beliefs and values of a particular society. Fyodor Dostoyevsky (1821-1881) once said “The degree of civilization in a society can be judged by entering its prisons.” (Pollock, 2010: 315). Punishment has been around since the beginning of civilization....   [tags: Criminal Justice System, Punishment]

Better Essays
2126 words (6.1 pages)

Utilitarian Theory of Punishment in the Criminal Justice System Essay example

- There is an ongoing problem in our society regarding punishment and responsibility. We, as a society, tend to look away when it comes to how criminals are being punished and maybe we should be paying more attention. Violence seems to be an integral part of our society, some raise their children with violence, we watch it on television, read it in newspapers and books and now we are even playing violent video games. When it comes to the judicial system the majority of citizens do not even know how individuals are being punished or if the punishment is too harsh, not severe enough or if the individual even needs punishment because what they may need is psychiatric help....   [tags: punishment, prisons, criminals]

Better Essays
769 words (2.2 pages)

Practice of Therapy Essay

- Practice of Therapy The actual practicing of therapy is a scary step for beginning therapists, although the education has been received and after practicum there will some experience in practicing with clients, doing therapy on your own seems intimidating. However, I am sure like most other experiences in life, the more you do something, the better you get at it and the more comfortable you feel in knowing what you are doing as well as doing it the proper way. With therapy, an individual can learn all about theories, models and assessments but the rapport and confidence from clients can only come after practicing therapy....   [tags: Counseling ]

Better Essays
1947 words (5.6 pages)

Goals of Group Therapy Essay

- Group therapy can become a very vital part of the social worker’s intervention with pre-delinquents and delinquents. If we look at group therapy with the delinquent population in terms of its objectives, it becomes apparent that group therapy can serve a number of important functions. One of the most important functions is the resocialization of the delinquent adolescent through contact with his peers (as well as an authority figure) in a real social situation. The fact that the group -- with its membership composed of fellow delinquents -- may have a greater situational resemblance to the real-life situation of the adolescent than an encounter with an individual therapist should enhance the...   [tags: Social Work ]

Better Essays
1830 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Rational Emotive Behavioral Therapy

- Gerald Corey in Theory and Practice of Counseling and Psychotherapy explains at times thoughts and feelings can be all consuming for people weather they are positive or negative. Unfortunately the negative thoughts have a way of permeating our views of ourselves. There are three thoughts that Albert Ellis would say everyone believes. One being we must do well and win the approval of others for my performances or else I am no good” (269). Second “Other people must treat me considerately, fairly, kindly, and in exactly the way I want them to treat me....   [tags: counseling, psychotherapy, language, emotions]

Better Essays
963 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Electroconvulsive Therapy: Why is it Effective?

- Electroconvulsive Therapy: Why is it Effective. Reported for the first time in the 18th century, was the use of convulsive therapy. Psychiatrists observed that after spontaneous epileptic seizure the psychiatric conditions of patients improved. Previously, in the sixteenth-century, Paracelsus, a Swiss physician and alchemist gave camphor by mouth to produce convulsions and to cure lunacy. Originally, the induced convulsions treated severe catatonic stupors and schizophrenia. Today we know the convulsions are secondary to grand mal seizures in the brain, and that the seizure is the primary therapeutic agent of electroconvuslive therapy (ECT)....   [tags: Medical Medicine Doctoral Essays]

Better Essays
2107 words (6 pages)

Art Therapy and the Disabled Essay

- Art Therapy and the Disabled In chapter twenty-one of the course textbook, the reader is presented with the case of Mrs. Day. Day was in an auto accident and it was necessary to amputate one of her feet. The chapter tells of Day’s progress through art therapy and the issues that had to be overcome in order for Mrs. Day to come to terms with her treatment. Outside research has shown that art therapy is useful in the eyes of the patient with a disability. The text speaks of the patient as a depressed thirty-five year old woman who after the accident refused to speak of the ordeal with staff or family....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
524 words (1.5 pages)

Essay on Capital Punishment

- Capital punishment is also known as death penalty and it is the execution of an individual in punishment of a crime. The word "capital" comes from Latin caput meaning head. Therefore the meaning of capital punishment, which can translate to decapitation. Decapitation was the preferred way of execution for long time. Other common ways of execution in Old America were hangings, burning, pressing, breaking on wheels and firing squads. Now a day lethal injection and electrocution are the choices for execution....   [tags: Current Events]

Better Essays
1149 words (3.3 pages)